Go Wild: Store-Bought Turkey Alternatives for the Holidays

Get your holiday centerpiece from wild turkey and other heriloom turkey breed producers this holiday season!

Roast duck

Adobe Stock

With turkey prices at record highs as Thanksgiving and Christmas approach, many consumers are looking for alternatives to the traditional main course for their holiday meals. As far as tradition goes, the rather sketchy details we do have about the first Thanksgiving meal celebrated by the Pilgrims and Wampanoag Indians at Plymouth in 1621 suggest that, while wild turkey was definitely available in plenty and mentioned in accounts specifically, other wild fowl – probably including duck, goose, swan, and perhaps other varieties – were also likely consumed. It is also recorded that venison was enjoyed in the form of five deer provided by the native tribesmen. Given their proximity to the ocean, it is highly likely that a variety of seafood – perhaps eels and shellfish, such as lobster, clams, and mussels – complemented the feast as well.

So, even tradition itself warrants branching out beyond turkey, and while we can’t guarantee that any of the suggestions offered here will necessarily prove more cost effective when all is said and done, perhaps variety itself provides its own justification. If you can’t find any of the alternatives mentioned above (or others) from your local grocer or other supplier, we have a few suggested online sources that you might want to try out:

allenbrothers.com
culverduck.com
manchesterfarms.com
wildforkfoods.com
silverfernfarms.com
blackwing.com
brokenarrowranch.com
dartagnan.com
honest-food.net
thespruceeats.com

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

Sgt. Strunk served as a gunner aboard an M48A2 tank while stationed in Germany during the Cold War as part of the US 3rd Infantry Division.
In celebration of Hank’s 100th birthday, we’ve attempted to distill his mammoth legacy down to the ten most influential songs.
Why is the moon visible at some times but not at others? Why is it always changing? We have explanations for these and other questions you might have asked about our nearest neighbor in the Solar System.
Cartoonist John Gruelle drew a smiling cartoon face onto the fabric of an old worn-out rag doll which his young daughter had found in the attic and called the doll “Raggedy Ann.”
Mr. Potato Head was first introduced in 1952. The first sets cost less than a dollar and included attachments only (hands, feet, eyes, etc.), with consumers supplying their own potatoes for the body.
From the earliest times, mankind strove to solve the problem of basic day-to-day survival by establishing a steady supply of food.