$8 Billion Farm Relief Program Faces Questions Over Payment Fairness

RFD-TV Farm Legal expert Roger McEowen said USDA should make the process transparent, ensure the formula reflects actual economic circumstances, and distribute assistance within the authority Congress has provided.

TOPEKA, KAN. (RFD-TV) — USDA’s $8 billion Harvest Fuel Relief program is intended to help farmers manage higher production costs, but questions remain about how payments will be calculated and whether assistance will reach the producers facing the greatest financial pressure.

Roger McEowen with Washburn University School of Law joined Market Day Report to examine the program’s payment formula, potential disadvantages for cow-calf ranchers, and the legal authority behind the federal assistance.

Payment Formula Raises Questions About Fairness

In his interview with RFD-TV, McEowen said one of his biggest concerns is whether the program’s formula will accurately reflect the financial challenges individual producers face.

USDA plans to use a uniform formula based on Farm Service Agency reported planted acres, Economic Research Service cost-of-production estimates, and USDA yield and price estimates to calculate a portion of modeled losses during the 2026 crop year. Commodity-specific payment rates for Title I crops are expected in November.

McEowen said relying heavily on historical production figures may not reflect which farmers are experiencing the greatest financial stress today.

He said transparency will be important in determining whether the $8 billion reaches producers who need the assistance most.

Cow-Calf Ranchers Could Face a Disadvantage

One concern involves how the proposed payment formula accounts for livestock operations, particularly cow-calf producers.

McEowen said ranchers face many of the same cost pressures as crop farmers, including higher fuel, feed, fertilizer, and transportation expenses. However, their production histories may not fit the formula as it is currently structured.

That could leave some cattle producers at a disadvantage, despite facing significant increases in operating costs.

He said the details of USDA’s payment methodology will be important in determining how livestock operations are considered.

Questions About USDA’s Legal Authority

The Harvest Fuel Relief program is being funded through the Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) Charter Act, which USDA says authorizes the $8 billion in payments.

McEowen said USDA has considerable authority under the act, but that discretion is not unlimited.

The department must demonstrate that the program fits within the purposes Congress authorized under the law.

“Having money available doesn’t mean USDA has an unlimited checkbook,” McEowen said.

He said the department also has an obligation to distribute taxpayer-funded assistance fairly and within the authority provided by Congress.

Repeated Emergency Payments Raise Concerns

McEowen said repeated rounds of federal farm assistance can create expectations that the government will step in whenever farm margins become tight.

While producers would generally prefer to earn income through the marketplace rather than rely on federal payments, he said recurring emergency assistance can influence production and investment decisions and shift more financial risk to taxpayers.

“Farm policy should provide a safety net, not eliminate the risks inherent in agriculture,” McEowen said.

He said a stronger long-term approach would emphasize Farm Bill programs, expanded domestic and export markets, affordable energy and fewer unnecessary regulatory burdens.

What Producers Should Do Now

McEowen said farmers and ranchers should document their expenses, review USDA eligibility requirements and talk with their lenders and tax advisers about cash flow and financing.

He noted that conversations with CPAs across the country suggest net cash farm income could be higher for many producers this year, even as expenses remain elevated.

He cautioned producers against making production or investment decisions based on the assumption that additional federal payments will be available.

“Don’t bank on that,” McEowen said.

LEARN MORE: Firm to Farm by Roger McEowen

Related Stories
What Farmers, Ranchers, and Business Owners Should Expect
Rising input costs and falling crop prices are pressuring farm finances. Joe Peiffer of Ag & Business Legal Strategies discusses warning signs and options for managing farm debt.
From growing food to welcoming visitors, FarmHER Dayla Ulrich of Sweet Pea Farm & Orchard says farming brings challenges, unexpected responsibilities, and plenty of reasons to enjoy the work. Her Dirt Diaries podcast episode is available this week.
Gruver Farm Scholarship Foundation President Chad Logsdon says converting harvests into scholarships invests in the next generation and helps students pursue college, technical training, and other careers.

Marion is a digital content manager for RFD-TV and FarmHER + RanchHER. She started working for Rural Media Group in May 2022, bringing a decade of digital experience in broadcast media and some cooking experience to the team.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

The suit names Corteva, Inc., Corteva Agriscience LLC, The Dow Chemical Company, and three nurseries, alleging that the pesticide makers failed to investigate or disclose neurological risks, and the nurseries failed to prevent off-site exposure.
Lewie Pugh says OOIDA plans to work with the next Congress on transportation policy, prioritizing truck parking, restroom access, and maintaining current liability insurance minimums.
NCBA Executive Director Sigrid Johannes says Senate Democrats now have less incentive to accept a lame-duck compromise when they expect to return in January with a much stronger majority.
Creighton economist Dr. Ernie Goss says farmland values and cash rents remain solid, but weak equipment sales and transportation costs challenge farm country.
RealAg Radio’s Lyndsey Smith says Canada’s budget extends farm succession tax breaks and expands ownership-transfer options, even though it excludes agriculture and forestry from the growth incentives offered to others.
Connected Nation data scientist David Nunnally says reliable internet, devices, and digital literacy connect rural residents to healthcare services and information, making broadband vital to state investments in rural healthcare.
Made Here, a national TV series developed and presented by the Industrial Solutions Network, showcases American manufacturing and the people, companies, partnerships, and communities shaping local economies and the industry’s future.
Farm CPA Paul Neiffer says estate tax exemption benefits could become targets for future tax reform if political control shifts again after 2028.
Superior Livestock’s Ralph Wade says they continue to see active marketing opportunities, with buyers placing value on cattle backed by strong genetics and health programs.
Harrison Pittman, director of the University of Arkansas’ National Agricultural Law Center, says Chapter 12 helps eligible family farms restructure debt and keep operating. Producers should understand their finances and seek professional guidance before a crisis.
Dr. Joana Colussi of Purdue’s agricultural economics department says farmers feel near-term financial relief but remain cautious about the months ahead.
ASFMRA CEO Amanda De Jong discusses farmland investment, data centers, technology and land ownership transitions at the organization’s annual conference in Phoenix.
Agriculture Shows
Agriculture is the most important industry in the world, and Ag PhD Daily brings you the information you need to best manage your business only on RFD-TV and RFDTV+
Hosted by Scott “The Cow Guy” Shellady, Commodity Talk on RFD-TV and Rural Radio SiriusXM Channel 143 delivers expert insight into today’s agricultural commodity markets just before the CME opens.
A look at the news, weather and commodities headlines that drove agriculture markets in the past week.