Firm to Farm: More BOI Follies

BOI reaches the Supreme Court.

SCOTUS-Building_GaryBlakeleyAdobeStock_27844626_1920x1080

Supreme Court Building in Washington, D.C.

Photo by Gary Blakeley

The Federal Government has filed an application with the U.S. Supreme Court to lift the stay of the nationwide preliminary injunction that the federal district court for the eastern district of Texas issued last month while the matter is pending on the merits in the courts. In its brief (150 pages), the government asserts that the BOI reporting requirements impose only a minimal burden on businesses and that the injunction is overbroad.

The Federal Government’s request goes to Justice Alito, who is responsible for emergency appeals from the 5th Circuit. He can act on the request on his own or he can direct the Federal Government to file a response. He also could simply refer the request to the full court.

Stay tuned. If you have attended my seminars or have followed my commentary on the BOI rules, you know that I have been saying all along that this would end up at the Supreme Court.

Maybe the incoming Congress will deal with the issue - once there is a new Congress that can do business. Will Chuck Grassley be President come January 20??? At least for a bit.

Agricultural Law and Taxation by Roger McEowen is a reader-supported publication on Substack. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Related Stories: Firm to Farm
As federal policy shifts toward greater tribal sovereignty, farmers and ranchers (and their legal counsel) must prioritize clear, written contracts and stay engaged with state legislative developments and tribal council updates.
Curing title defects in an agricultural context requires a blend of traditional real estate law and a deep understanding of rural land use history.
The agricultural installment land contract remains a sophisticated tool for transitioning farm assets, but its success depends entirely on the technical integrity of the written agreement.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

The Mengel Dairy Farms case is a sobering reminder that “having insurance” is not the same as “having protection.”
For producers, the cost of doing business is no longer determined solely by feed, fuel, and weather—it is increasingly a matter of navigating the differing legal philosophies of every state line they cross.
For producers, success this season will require more than just a clean field; it will require meticulous record-keeping, a proactive written mitigation plan, and a constant eye on both the forecast and the federal docket.
The most common mistake farmers make is waiting until a health crisis occurs to transfer the farm to their children.
For the broader agricultural industry, a railroad antitrust case in Kansas could lead to the dismantling of legacy regulatory shields, creating a more fluid, market-driven transportation grid that prioritizes moving crops efficiently over protecting historic rail monopolies.