Firm to Farm: The Judiciary — Is It the Most Dangerous Branch for Agriculture? (Part 2)

Property Rights, Government Accountability, and the Use of Litigation Against Agriculture

Justice with grain fields behind

Photo by Rosso and fotoinfot via Adobe Stock

TOPEKA, Kan. (Firm to Farm) — The judiciary’s relationship with American agriculture is complicated. Courts can serve as an essential constitutional safeguard, protecting farmers and ranchers against government overreach, infringement of property rights, and arbitrary agency action. But litigation can also become a powerful instrument for advancing regulatory and political objectives that might otherwise be difficult to accomplish through legislation.

From disputes over agricultural land use and environmental regulation to federal prosecutions arising out of property-boundary disagreements, the growing use of litigation has significant consequences for agricultural producers. This second installment examines both sides of that judicial influence, asking whether the courts are consistently protecting the constitutional rights of agricultural landowners or, in some instances, becoming another avenue through which those rights are threatened.

The Constitution Still Matters on the Farm

Several important Supreme Court decisions demonstrate that the judiciary can also serve as a critical protector of agricultural property rights. Consider Horne v. Department of Agriculture.[1] California raisin growers challenged a federal marketing order requiring them to set aside a portion of their crop. The USDA’s enforcement efforts resulted in substantial monetary penalties. The Supreme Court ultimately held that the government could not take the growers’ raisins without providing constitutionally required compensation. The case stands for an important proposition: property rights do not disappear simply because the property happens to be agricultural.

The same principle appeared in Cedar Point Nursery v. Hassid.[2] California required agricultural employers to allow union organizers onto their property for specified periods of time. The Supreme Court held that the regulation constituted a per se physical taking under the Fifth Amendment. Again, the message was straightforward: government cannot simply commandeer private agricultural property without constitutional consequences.

These cases are important because they demonstrate what the judiciary is supposed to do. The judiciary should not become an additional regulatory agency. It should enforce the Constitution and the laws enacted by the people’s representatives.

Litigation Can Be Used from Either Direction

There is another dimension to agricultural lawfare that deserves attention. Lawfare does not necessarily require a government agency to sue a farmer. Private organizations can use litigation to challenge government actions that benefit agriculture. Environmental organizations, animal-rights organizations, and other advocacy groups have statutory causes of action and procedural tools that can produce enormous consequences for agricultural operations.

The Central Oregon LandWatch v. Jefferson County litigation provides a recent illustration of how land-use litigation can affect agricultural property. In 2026, the Oregon Court of Appeals addressed litigation surrounding a 142.5-acre parcel zoned for range land and whether grazing remained a practicable agricultural use.[3] The court emphasized that the parcel’s inability to support an independently profitable farming operation did not mean grazing ceased to constitute a legitimate farm use.

The case itself is not evidence of judicial hostility toward agriculture. Quite the contrary – the decision recognized the continuing agricultural character of the land. But the litigation illustrates something farmers understand intuitively: The legal system can determine whether land remains agricultural without anyone ever putting a plow in the ground. A lawsuit can challenge a zoning decision. Another can challenge an environmental permit. Another can challenge a federal agency’s approval. Another can seek an injunction. Another can force an environmental review. Each individual lawsuit may have a legitimate legal basis. Collectively, however, litigation can impose enormous transaction costs on agriculture. That distinction matters.

Criticizing litigation-driven regulation does not mean that environmental organizations should be denied access to the courts. Nor does it mean that every lawsuit against a farmer, rancher, or agricultural agency is “lawfare.” The rule of law requires courts to hear legitimate claims. The question is whether the legal system is being used to resolve genuine legal disputes – or whether litigation is being used strategically to impose economic and political consequences that could not be achieved through legislation.

The Maude Family: When a Boundary Dispute Becomes a Federal Prosecution

The Charles and Heather Maude case is perhaps the clearest recent example of why USDA has adopted the term “lawfare.” The Maudes, fifth-generation South Dakota ranchers, became embroiled in a dispute with the U.S. Forest Service concerning a fence and approximately 50 acres (25 acres of the Maudes’ land adjacent to the Buffalo Gap National Grasslands and 25 acres of federal land).[4] What began as a property-boundary dispute ultimately resulted in federal criminal indictments against the couple in 2024. The charges were later dismissed in April 2025 after the Trump Administration took office.[5] USDA itself subsequently identified the Maude matter as an example of what it characterized as politically motivated agricultural lawfare.

Reasonable lawyers can disagree about the government’s underlying legal position. But a larger principle applies here. The power to prosecute is among the most formidable powers the government possesses. When a longstanding property dispute can escalate into felony charges against a farm or ranch family, every agricultural landowner should pay attention. The cost is not merely attorneys’ fees. It is lost time, lost production, damaged reputation, family stress, financing problems, and the possibility that a multigenerational agricultural operation may not survive the dispute.

Boucher and the Limits of USDA’s Swampbuster Authority

The Boucher litigation provides an important counterpoint to the Maude matter because it demonstrates that courts can (and sometimes do) serve as an effective check on federal overreach. In Boucher v. USDA,[6] the USDA treated several acres of an Indiana farm as converted wetlands under the Swampbuster provisions of the Food Security Act after the farmer had removed nine trees. The consequence was potentially sweeping: the entire farm became ineligible for USDA program benefits. The Seventh Circuit reversed, concluding that the agency’s determination was arbitrary and capricious. The USDA had disregarded evidence that the disputed acreage lacked the hydrology necessary to qualify as wetlands, relied on an inappropriate comparison site, and shifted its explanations during the administrative process and litigation.

The court’s analysis is significant for agricultural landowners. Vegetation removal, standing alone, did not relieve USDA of its obligation to determine whether the statutory elements of a wetland were present. Hydrology mattered. The agency could not substitute assumptions, an unsuitable comparison site, or post hoc explanations for a reasoned determination supported by the administrative record. The court emphasized that an agency must examine the relevant data, consider important aspects of the problem, and articulate a rational connection between the facts found and the decision made. That is the essence of meaningful judicial review under the Administrative Procedure Act.[7]

Boucher is especially useful when evaluating the balance between environmental objectives and the rights of agricultural producers. Swampbuster is a congressional policy choice, and USDA has authority to administer it. But that authority is not unlimited. A producer should not lose eligibility for farm program benefits because an agency applies its own rules inconsistently or fails to establish the factual predicates Congress required. In this respect, Boucher illustrates the judiciary at its best: enforcing the law as written rather than deferring to an agency simply because the dispute involves technical subject matter.

Conclusion

The cases discussed above demonstrate that courts can serve as an important check on government power. But agricultural lawfare is not confined to federal agencies or federal courtrooms. State environmental enforcement, federal land-management decisions, and broader conservation initiatives can create additional litigation risks for farmers and ranchers. These disputes are particularly consequential because agricultural operations depend on access to land, water, and infrastructure. The next installment examines several current examples and considers what they reveal about the growing intersection of environmental policy, administrative enforcement, and judicial power.

FOOTNOTES:
[1] 569 U.S. 513 (2013).
[2] 594 U.S. 139 (2021).
[3] Central Oregon LandWatch v. Jefferson County, 347 Or. App. 454, 586 P.3d 957 (2026).
[4] See United States v. Maude, Nos. 5:24-cr-50081 and 5:24-cr-50082 (D.S.D. 2024); Jennifer Carrico, The Maudes and the US Forest Service: How a Fence Line Dispute Almost Tore a Family Apart, DTN/Progressive Farmer (Jan. 21, 2026).
[5] United States v. Maude, No. 5:24-cr-50081 (D.S.D. Apr. 28, 2025) (order granting the government’s motion to dismiss the indictment without prejudice).
[6] Boucher v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, 934 F.3d 530 (7th Cir. 2019).
[7] 5 U.S.C. § 706(2)(A).

Recent Posts by Roger McEowen

Read more of Roger McEowen’s thoughts on agricultural law and policy issues that matter to farmers and ranchers on his RFD Business Blog, Firm to Farm.

Litigation, Regulatory Uncertainty, and the Changing Role of the Courts
What Farmers, Ranchers, and Business Owners Should Expect
For farmers and ranchers, a dog attacking livestock is more than a nuisance — it can threaten animals, livelihoods, and years of investment — but the law generally does not recognize a blanket right to shoot a dog simply for trespassing.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers are considering new WOTUS definitions following the Supreme Court’s Sackett decision, with implications for farmers, ranchers and rural landowners.
Deliberately falsifying production records or other material information to obtain benefits can lead to consequences far beyond repayment. The case involving Missouri farmer Steve McBee illustrates the point.
USDA’s Harvest Fuel Relief Program could provide short-term assistance to farmers, but ranchers await clarity on payments for fuel, feed, and cattle hauling.
A government agency may have authority to regulate groundwater, but that authority does not eliminate the agency’s obligation to respect statutory limits and established property rights.
A recent decision from the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Kansas addresses an important question: Can a farmer modify a confirmed Chapter 12 plan to extend payments on secured debt beyond five years from the date the first payment under the original plan was due?
Roger McEowen examines how President Trump’s federal diesel tax relief differs from state rules and what Kansas farmers should consider before using dyed diesel on roads.
A recent Wyoming Supreme Court ruling reminds farmers and ranchers that disputes over land access are, ultimately, disputes over property rights.
A Ninth Circuit ruling says federal sovereign immunity does not automatically bar ranchers from enforcing state-adjudicated water rights.
A Lesson in Administrative Law from South Carolina
Cooper-Clark highlights a key lesson for producers and royalty owners: in oil-and-gas royalty disputes, lease language and marketing facts are crucial.
The government should exercise humility before imposing costs on an economy as complex as American agriculture. The 2026 greenhouse-gas regulatory rollback reflects that shift.
A botched art deal demonstrates the dangers of relying on informal understandings when money changes hands.