TOPEKA, KAN. (RFD-TV) — Court decisions and legal challenges are playing an increasingly influential role in shaping agricultural policy, creating new concerns for farmers and ranchers over property rights, regulatory authority, and the cost of litigation.
Roger McEowen of Washburn University School of Law joined Market Day Report for the first part of a series examining legal issues affecting agriculture. He discussed the growing concern over agricultural lawfare and several court decisions involving federal agencies, environmental regulations, and landowner rights.
The Judiciary’s Growing Influence on Agriculture
In his interview with RFD-TV, McEowen said the judiciary has historically been viewed as the branch of government responsible for protecting individual liberties and enforcing the law. However, he said litigation increasingly influences agricultural policy.
Courts can stop projects, restrict land use, invalidate permits and establish regulatory requirements through judicial decisions.
McEowen said his concern is that courts sometimes move beyond interpreting the law and begin making policy decisions that should belong to Congress and state legislatures.
For farmers and ranchers, he said, that distinction can have significant economic consequences.
Understanding Agricultural Lawfare
U.S. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins has identified agricultural lawfare as a concern for the industry.
McEowen described it as the use of administrative, legal, and legislative government systems to adversely affect farmers, ranchers, and agricultural producers.
He said government does not necessarily have to pass another regulation to create challenges for agricultural operations. Litigation, administrative enforcement and even the threat of criminal prosecution can have similar effects.
McEowen pointed to disputes involving grazing rights, property boundaries, environmental regulations and land use as examples of issues that can become expensive legal battles.
He said the legal system itself can become another cost of doing business in agriculture.
The Frank Robbins Case and Property Rights
McEowen discussed the case of Wyoming rancher Frank Robbins, who was involved in a dispute with the Bureau of Land Management over an easement across his private property.
After Robbins refused to grant the government the easement, he alleged that BLM officials subjected him to years of harassment and intimidation. He was eventually criminally prosecuted, but a jury acquitted him in less than 30 minutes.
McEowen said the case raises concerns about the difficulty of obtaining relief for alleged government misconduct, even after successfully defending against criminal charges.
He said the Supreme Court ultimately ruled that Robbins could not pursue the damages claims he had brought against federal officials.
The case, McEowen said, illustrates how difficult it can be for farmers and ranchers to obtain meaningful legal relief when challenging government actions.
Sackett v. EPA Clarifies Federal Wetlands Authority
McEowen said the Supreme Court’s decision in Sackett v. EPA was significant for agricultural landowners because it limited federal jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act.
The decision rejected the EPA’s expansive interpretation of federal wetlands authority and established that covered wetlands must have a continuous surface connection to relatively permanent waters to fall under federal jurisdiction.
McEowen said the ruling provides greater certainty for landowners whose routine activities can involve draining fields, moving dirt, constructing ponds, repairing roads, building barns and improving pastures.
Without clear jurisdictional boundaries, he said, those activities could raise federal permitting concerns.
Loper Bright Changes Agency Authority
McEowen also discussed the Supreme Court’s Loper Bright decision, which overturned the Chevron deference doctrine.
For approximately 40 years, the Chevron doctrine generally required courts to defer to reasonable federal agency interpretations of ambiguous statutes. McEowen said that gave agencies considerable influence over how the laws they administered were interpreted.
Under Loper Bright, courts must now exercise their own independent judgment when determining whether federal agencies have statutory authority.
McEowen said the decision is particularly important for agriculture because farmers and ranchers are regulated by numerous federal agencies, including USDA, EPA, the Army Corps of Engineers, the Fish and Wildlife Service and the Bureau of Land Management.
Those agencies continue to administer the law, he said, but they no longer receive the same deference when interpreting what the law means.
Environmental Litigation and Agricultural Operations
McEowen pointed to Held v. State of Montana as another case with potential implications for agriculture.
The case involved young plaintiffs challenging Montana’s energy policies under the state’s constitutional environmental protections. The Montana Supreme Court recognized a constitutional right to a stable climate system and invalidated a statutory restriction on considering greenhouse gas emissions in certain environmental reviews.
McEowen said the decision did not prohibit farming or ranching but could open the door to additional litigation involving energy development and environmental permitting.
He said future legal challenges could affect livestock facilities, irrigation projects, rural energy development and infrastructure.
His concern is that environmental litigation could become a way to impose policy restrictions that would be difficult to achieve through the legislative process.
READ MORE: Firm to Farm
Read more of Roger McEowen’s thoughts on agricultural law and policy issues that matter to farmers and ranchers on his RFD Business Blog, Firm to Farm.