USDA Deputy Secretary Vaden: BARC Closure Raises Questions on Federal Spending and Facility Conditions

On Tuesday’s Cow Guy Close, host Scott Shellady spoke with USDA Deputy Secretary Stephen Vaden about the decision, what he saw during a recent tour of the property, and why the department believes closure is the best path forward.

vaden at barc_USDA.PNG

A video still of USDA Deputy Secretary Stephen Vaden touring the dilapidated BARC facilities in Maryland.

U.S. Department of Agriculture

WASHINGTON, D.C. (Cow Guy Close) — The future of the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center (BARC) is under scrutiny after the U.S. Department of Agriculture announced plans to close the aging Maryland facility, citing extensive deferred maintenance, deteriorating infrastructure, and rising costs.

On Tuesday’s Cow Guy Close, host Scott Shellady spoke with USDA Deputy Secretary Stephen Vaden about the decision, what he saw during a recent tour of the property, and why the department believes closure is the best path forward.

Q&A with USDA Deputy Secretary Stephen Vaden

Scott “The Cow Guy” Shellady: There’s an interesting — or actually a big — story about a piece of property in suburban Washington, D.C. It’s called the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center, or BARC for short. It’s kind of a cross between a massive university and a medium-sized city. It’s got its own power plants and the like. It’s slated for closure by USDA as upkeep and one-off maintenance issues have become, quite simply, untenable.

What are your thoughts after touring the facility?

USDA Deputy Secretary Stephen Vaden: Well, it’s sad, just to put a period on it. We have more than 400 buildings on that campus in Beltsville, Maryland, and half of them are waiting to be torn down because they are in such abominable condition.

We’ve got four-story buildings where the sprinkler system activated and flooded all four floors. We have a building where a tree is literally growing through the center of it. We have abandoned greenhouses. We have abandoned buildings of all types.

And the taxpayers are being asked to pay for it, all the while our USDA scientists in similarly decrepit facilities located on the campus are being asked to conduct world-leading agricultural research. That’s impossible. It’s not taking science seriously, and it’s not using the resources taxpayers have given us wisely.

So what we’re doing, as you’ve shown, is closing this ancient, underfunded, decrepit facility down and moving these important research projects to the 94 other Agricultural Research Service labs where they can be done in modern, state-of-the-art facilities, which are usually co-located with our land-grant institutions.

Scott Shellady: I’m going to ask permission to ask a stupid question because I don’t really want to know the answer, but I’m going to do it anyway. Are you getting pushback against this common-sense closure?

Stephen Vaden: Yes, we are. And most interestingly, we’re getting it from the Maryland congressional delegation.

This facility is in Maryland. As you know, Maryland has had some incredibly important members of Congress. As a matter of fact, over the last decade or so, a Maryland senator has served as chair of the Appropriations Committee in the Senate, and in the House of Representatives, Representative Steny Hoyer has served in the past as chair of the House Appropriations Committee.

So despite having these senior leaders who are literally responsible for appropriating money for the entire federal government — and despite how important they claim these Beltsville, Maryland, facilities are today — they didn’t appropriate one extra dime to fix them up.

They have allowed, in their own backyard, this decay to continue. And now that we’re taking the obvious step to close it down, they’re throwing a fit, even though their own Office of Special Counsel, in an investigation begun under the previous administration, wrote a formal report saying this facility was a hazard for USDA employees to continue to work at, and its decay was entirely because of inadequate congressional funding that they control.

Scott Shellady: I mean, I’m shocked, but I’m not shocked because it seems like this is happening more and more often nowadays. That is the flag bearer for why we have a problem with $39 trillion in debt and why we have waste, fraud, and abuse.

Stephen Vaden: Well, that’s right. And we have 94 other research facilities for which taxpayers are already paying, which are modern, state-of-the-art, and frequently located at some of the leading research universities in this country.

Why in the world wouldn’t we conduct this important scientific research at modern facilities taxpayers have already purchased?

Instead of closing down this facility in Maryland — which, as you’ve seen from the video, is an embarrassment that we ask scientists to work there at all.

Scott Shellady: And then we’re expected, as USDA leadership, to go out there and recruit the best talent and brightest minds, then bring them back to this pig pen. Who’s going to want to take that job?

Stephen Vaden: Well, you’ve hit the nail on the head.

If you were to look at our org chart for Beltsville, we have multiple positions for which we have appropriations from Congress that remain unfilled.

Would you want to work there? Would you want to work at a facility where nearly every year another building closes because of improper maintenance or some other hazard?

Would you want to work in a town — and I think that’s how you adequately described it in terms of its size, its hundreds and hundreds of acres — where half of the buildings are vacant and literally falling apart?

Is that a great work environment for anyone?

And then you add on top of that, you’re expected to do cutting-edge, world-leading science in such a facility. It makes a mockery of it.

Scott Shellady: Common sense should rule the day. And I’d say, hey, if these Maryland legislators really want it that bad, they can pay for it themselves — but not out of the money that should be going to American farmers.

Stephen Vaden: Well, think about it. During the previous administration, they were not averse to spending money, as we all know. That’s what led to the inflation we’re dealing with the side effects from.

They spent trillions of dollars like it was a hundred-dollar bill, and yet with all of that spending — and all of these complaints from the Maryland congressional delegation about how vital this facility is — at a time when literally no one was minding the store in terms of spending, they couldn’t find an extra dime for Beltsville.

That tells you the whole story of why this facility is in the shape that it’s in.

And I’m sorry, I truly am, that they have allowed this facility to get into the condition that it has, but we have a responsibility to use taxpayer resources wisely, and we’re not going to continue throwing money into this pit that they have refused to fix for years.

Related Stories
Groundbreaking Marks Next Major Milestone in Strengthening U.S. New World Screwworm Preparedness
The 91st anniversary of Black Sunday highlights how the Dust Bowl disaster led to modern soil conservation programs still shaping U.S. agriculture today.
Steven Snow with the U.S. Small Business Administration joined us to discuss tax relief for rural Americans and the long-term benefits of new provisions impacting farmers and small businesses.
A new partnership with the Montana Beef Council is bringing protein-packed refuel stations to high school sports tournaments across the state.
As budget hearings continue on Capitol Hill, policymakers focus on long-term solutions to stabilize the fertilizer market to support U.S. farmers.
Rising global supplies may cap soybean price strength, while sorghum prices hinge heavily on China’s export demand.

Marion is a digital content manager for RFD News and FarmHER + RanchHER. She started working for Rural Media Group in May 2022, bringing a decade of digital experience in broadcast media and some cooking experience to the team.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

Oklahoma Cattlemen’s Michael Kelsey joined us to discuss wildfire impacts across the Southern Plains, the importance of community support, and the path forward for affected producers.
As ag lawmakers in the Senate await the House vote on the Farm Bill, they are eager to discuss the challenges farmers face before it is their turn to take up the critical legislation.
Elena Chavez with Halter provided insight into the company’s virtual fencing technology, its adoption in the U.S., and the impact of recent funding on ranching operations.
Brooks York with AgriSompo addresses how current market conditions and risk management are impacted by volatility in the Middle East, and considerations for farmers in the spring planting season.
The Biden Administration launched the Increasing Land, Capital, and Market Access (ILCMA) program in 2023 to help underserved farmers facing barriers to land ownership.
Farm CPA Paul Neiffer provided guidance on navigating the R&D tax credit, emphasizing record-keeping, eligibility, and maximizing potential savings as crop margins remain the key pressure point for farmers.