Firm to Farm: Settling Boundary and Survey Disputes in Agriculture

RFD-TV ag law and tax expert Roger McEowen with the Washburn School of Law dives into common disputes over boundaries and conflicting surveys in agriculture.

SDRanchlandBarbedWireFence_SchausCreativeLLC-AdobeStock_519881601_1920x1080.jpg

Schaus Creative LLC - stock.adobe.com

Boundary issues are not uncommon in rural settings.

What if a survey doesn’t match an existing fence line? How is the actual legal property boundary determined? Can an existing fence not placed on the actual surveyed line between two tracts of farmland become the legal boundary? How do disagreements get resolved?

These are some of the common boundary questions.

Boundary issues in agriculture — that’s the topic of today’s Firm to Farm blog post by RFD-TV ag law and tax expert Roger McEowen with the Washburn School of Law.

What is a Boundary?

Landowners generally consider existing fences to be the boundary between adjacent properties. But the law may view things differently. The actual boundary is an imaginary line that can be found by examining the deeds to the adjacent properties. An existing fence line is merely evidence of the location of the boundary line between the properties. It is immaterial whether the fence is a permanent fence or not.

However, there may be situations where the fence line has become part of the property description over time as the land changes hands. The fence line may be considered the legal property boundary in that situation. But, if a parcel is described by mapping out survey lines, an existing fence may not be on the surveyed boundary. Instead, the adjacent owners may have treated that old fence as the boundary. When that happens, the old fence can be substituted for the actual legal boundary under the doctrine of practical location.

Once that fence has been used as the boundary for a set period (defined by state law), it can become the legal boundary by filing a court action to quiet title. In the ag setting, boundaries are often determined by usage rather than by survey.

Misplaced Fence as a Legal Boundary

An existing fence may not be on the surveyed boundary, but there are ways it can become the legal boundary between separate tracts of farmland. While the mere passage of time does not cause a fence line to be substituted for the actual property boundary, the manner in which the adjacent property owners have used the property over time might. This is true if the party claiming title to a disputed area knows that the existing fence line is not on the property boundary and uses the additional property between the true boundary and the fence line as their own.

If the true boundary is unknown, courts typically examine the intent of the party benefiting from the misplaced fence. If the property is occupied by mere mistake, the boundary won’t change. But, if one party possesses the property believing the land to be his up to the mistaken line and claims title to it, the boundary can shift if the true owner knows of the other party’s assertion of ownership and does nothing to prevent if for a period of time set by state law. This is known as adverse possession.

A boundary that changes based on these facts is formalized by a “quiet title” action in court.

Settling Boundary Disagreements & Conflicting Surveys

What are some ways to resolve boundary disputes that are short of going to court? For starters, check the land records to see if there is a recorded fence agreement. While uncommon, if an agreement exists, it will bind the adjacent landowners.

Another way to settle a dispute over an uncertain boundary is for the parties to execute a memorandum of understanding designating the existing fence line as the boundary. The memo can also be recorded in the land records. Once recorded, it will bind the present and subsequent owners of the property and their successors.

If a boundary remains in dispute because of conflicting surveys, any boundaries and markers set by the first survey conflict with a subsequent survey. This is true even if the original survey contained errors.

When a boundary dispute involves a disagreement between surveys, consider how the use of the land has been affected by the original survey’s location of the boundary. If the fence was erected along the old but erroneous survey line, and the parties have actively farmed to the fence line, the fence should not be moved. If the fence does not follow either the original survey or the later survey, the true boundary line may need to be designated.

Conclusion

Boundary disputes are not uncommon when agricultural land is involved. Hopefully, this brief review provides some insight. You can find more ag law and tax insights from Roger McEowen on his Substack blog:

Recent Posts by Roger McEowen

Read more of Roger McEowen’s thoughts on agricultural law and policy issues that matter to farmers and ranchers on his RFD Business Blog, Firm to Farm.

Property Rights, Government Accountability, and the Use of Litigation Against Agriculture
Litigation, Regulatory Uncertainty, and the Changing Role of the Courts
What Farmers, Ranchers, and Business Owners Should Expect

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

CoBank expects cattle supplies to remain tight through 2027, with stronger herd rebuilding possible in 2028.
Unfinished Farm Bill priorities could face a fresh start in January if lawmakers fail to act before year-end.
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
7:30 PM EST | 6:30 PM CST | 5:30 PM MST | 4:30 PM PST
The increase in dollars borrowed comes as producers continue to face elevated costs for fertilizer, fuel, machinery, labor, and other operating expenses.
Tyson’s Amarillo expansion could create additional competition for fed cattle, but the price impact will depend on how quickly slaughter volumes and cattle procurement increase.
Consumer prices rose 0.4 percent in October, with food prices up 0.5 percent and energy costs increasing 0.7 percent, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Consumer Price Index.
Farm Bureau analysis shows harvest prices finished above spring crop insurance prices for all four crops for only the second time since 2011.
USDA’s Grain Transportation Report says the average Class I railroad fuel surcharge climbed to 76 cents per mile in November, up 231 percent from April.
Final grazing regulations from the Bureau of Land Management could reshape permit administration and land access for western ranchers for years to come.
New federal grazing policies could give western ranchers greater access to available forage.
Dow Jones Energy says 2026 diesel price spikes are driven primarily by limited refining capacity and limited middle-distillate availability.
Federal efforts to strengthen domestic mineral production are helping revive mines across the western U.S.