Routine Soybean Insecticide Spraying Rarely Delivers a Yield Return on Investment

Think applying an insecticide to your soybean field automatically pays for itself? You would be mistaken. University of Illinois Extension field crops entomologist Nick Seiter says it does not.

NASHVILLE, TENN. (RFD NEWS) — If insecticide applications are part of a routine soybean production program, new research suggests some growers may be spending money without seeing a yield benefit.

Nick Seiter, Field Crops Entomologist with the University of Illinois Extension, says researchers have spent the past three years evaluating the return on investment of insecticides applied to soybean seed and at different growth stages, including R3 and R5.

“For the last three years, we have been doing work looking at insecticide return on investment. [...] to see how often that provides a return in terms of soybean yield and what that does to the insect populations out there,” Seiter explains.

He says the trials have generally found pest populations staying below levels where an insecticide application would be expected to pay.

“The general overview we have seen so far is that we very rarely exceed the economic threshold of an insect pest,” Seiter continues. “The recommendations we have for when an insecticide is likely to provide a return have not been exceeded in these trials, and we have not returned a yield from those insecticides.”

Seiter recommends using insecticides when pest populations reach an economic threshold rather than applying them preventively.

Related Stories
Fred Nichols explains how crop residue can provide valuable nutrients and help protect soil, but farmers need to consider how to make those nutrients available for the next crop.
Paul Mitchell of Imogene Ingredients says a recent University of Nebraska feedlot trial found Farmatan improved cattle weight and feed efficiency and reduced liver abscesses versus controls.
President Donald Trump plans to sign an executive order to lower diesel costs, including expanding access to tax-exempt dyed diesel as farmers face high harvest fuel prices.
Higher crop prices could keep 2027 cash rents from falling as much as expected.

Marion is a digital content manager for RFD News and FarmHER + RanchHER. She started working for Rural Media Group in May 2022, bringing a decade of digital experience in broadcast media and some cooking experience to the team.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

Ohio’s 90-day fuel-tax suspension provides temporary relief as farmers work through harvest, but Ohio Farm Bureau President Brad Bales says longer-term solutions are needed to address higher production costs.
Farm Aid Co-Executive Director Jen Fahy discusses the challenges facing family farmers, from rising costs and weather to land-use pressures.
USDA has added more than 30 million base acres to ARC and PLC and expanded crop insurance options and regenerative agriculture funding.
Creighton University’s Rural Mainstreet Index finds that higher input costs and tariffs are pressuring farm income, equipment sales, and the rural economy.
CoBank research shows that higher butterfat and protein levels can add hundreds of dollars per cow in dairy revenue as milk components become more important to profitability.
AEM’s Austin Gellings says AI is becoming more practical in farm equipment, helping farmers improve efficiency, manage data, and use technologies such as targeted applications and automation.
Agriculture Shows
Agriculture is the most important industry in the world, and Ag PhD Daily brings you the information you need to best manage your business only on RFD-TV and RFD+
Hosted by Scott “The Cow Guy” Shellady and RFD News Markets Specialist Tony St. James, Commodity Talk delivers expert insight into the day’s ag commodity markets just before the CME opens. Only on RFD-TV and Rural Radio SiriusXM Channel 147.
A look at the news, weather and commodities headlines that drove agriculture markets in the past week.