WTO Appeals Paralysis Weakens Global Agricultural Trade Enforcement

A stalled World Trade Organization appeals body increases long-term trade policy risk for U.S. agriculture.

World News_Adobe Stock.png

Adobe Stock

GENEVA, SWITZERLAND (RFD NEWS) — U.S. agricultural exporters face growing uncertainty as the World Trade Organization’s Appellate Body remains non-functioning, leaving trade disputes without a final enforcement mechanism. The breakdown limits predictability in a system designed to protect market access.

At Tuesday’s Dispute Settlement Body meeting, Colombia — speaking for 130 members — introduced for the 95th time a proposal to begin filling Appellate Body vacancies. The United States again blocked the move, citing unresolved concerns about judicial overreach and procedural violations.

Farm-Level Takeaway: A stalled WTO appeals body increases long-term trade policy risk for U.S. agriculture.
Tony St. James, RFD NEWS Markets Specialist

Washington has prevented new appointments since 2017, following rulings it argues exceeded negotiated mandates — including agriculture cases such as Brazil’s challenge to U.S. cotton subsidies and GSM-102 export credit guarantees.

Without a quorum, countries can appeal panel decisions “into the void,” halting enforcement. This was on display this week after a panel ruling suspending the adoption of a panel ruling on U.S. Inflation Reduction Act tax credits was appealed by the United States.

Several members continue to urge the restoration of the full dispute system, but absent a reform agreement, paralysis is likely to persist.

Related Stories
Roger McEowen explains the concept of “lawfare” — the use of legal systems to intimidate or financially exhaust an opponent — which grew into a central theme of U.S. ag law in 2025.
Tennessee 4-H members Jayden Hesson and Matthew Rochford joined us to discuss how 4-H is helping young leaders plan for the future of agriculture.
Greater transparency into USDA-backed lending can help rural lenders and producers better assess credit availability and investment trends.
Mixed product pricing and rising milk supplies suggest margin management will remain critical as 2026 unfolds.
Roger McEowen, with the Washburn School of Law, offers an in-depth look at two of the top legal issues of 202. Today, he walks through last year’s Waters of the United States (WOTUS) ruling and “lawfare.”
The West Carroll Parish Ag Expo represents more than farming — it is about the future of agriculture, where tradition meets innovation, and where the backbone of Northeast Louisiana continues to thrive.

Tony St. James joined the RFD-TV talent team in August 2024, bringing a wealth of experience and a fresh perspective to RFD-TV and Rural Radio Channel 147 Sirius XM. In addition to his role as Market Specialist (collaborating with Scott “The Cow Guy” Shellady to provide radio and TV audiences with the latest updates on ag commodity markets), he hosts “Rural America Live” and serves as talent for trade shows.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

Clearer 45Z rules favor U.S. oilseeds, but final RFS volumes remain critical to locking in demand.
Even small declines in the calf crop translate into sustained supply pressure, supporting cattle prices over multiple years.
Clear right-to-repair guidance reduces downtime, repair costs, and operational risk.
Winter Weather And Markets Reshape Agriculture Nationwide This Week
Shrinking sheep numbers contrast with gradual goat expansion, signaling tighter lamb supplies but steadier growth potential for meat goats.
Falling livestock prices, combined with higher input costs, continue to squeeze farm profitability heading into 2026.