Firm to Farm: Acreage Anxiety—How Zoning Issues Can Limit Your Rural Property Dreams

The allure of rural property — with its promise of space, freedom, and self-sufficiency — is undeniable, but local zoning regulations govern the reality.

Buying a rural property is an exciting prospect, offering privacy and freedom, but it comes with unique challenges, most notably zoning and land-use restrictions. Before committing to a purchase, it is absolutely critical to confirm the land’s current zoning classification and understand the local regulations to ensure you can use the property as intended.

———

Understanding Rural Zoning Classifications

Zoning is the process by which local governments (typically county or municipal) regulate how land within their jurisdiction can be used. Rural properties often fall into categories designed to preserve agricultural character and manage low-density development.

Common Rural Zoning Types

Classification
Typical Purpose
Key Restrictions to Check
Agricultural (A or AG)
Preserves farmland, livestock production, and open space.
Minimum acreage for a single home, limits on non-agricultural commercial uses (e.g., a commercial event venue), and potential limits on livestock density.
Rural Residential (R-A or R-R)
A hybrid of residential and limited agricultural activity.
Minimum lot size (often large, like 3, 5, or 10 acres), restrictions on subdivision, and regulations on accessory buildings (size, height, or use).
Exclusive Farm Use (EFU)
Strictly limits non-agricultural development to protect high-value farmland.
Severe restrictions on residential buildings (often only one per parcel), and virtually no commercial or industrial use allowed.
Unzoned/Unrestricted
Some remote counties may have no zoning ordinances.
While this offers the most freedom from zoning, you must check county-level building and health codes (septic/well), as well as deed restrictions.

Crucial Zoning & Use Restrictions to Verify

Your intended use might be perfectly reasonable in one rural area and strictly prohibited in another. To avoid costly surprises, you must investigate the following specific restrictions:

  • Permitted Uses: Is your primary goal (e.g., building a single-family home, starting a vineyard, running a small timber operation) an “allowed use,” a “conditional use” (requiring a special permit/review), or a “prohibited use”?
  • Residential Density: How many dwellings are permitted on the property? If you plan to build a second home, a guest house (Accessory Dwelling Unit or ADU), or eventually subdivide, check the minimum lot size requirements.
  • Home-Based Business: Can you run your specific business (e.g., auto repair, ceramic studio, short-term rental) from the property? Most zoning regulations have strict rules on business types, traffic volume, signage, and employees allowed on residential or agricultural land.
  • Accessory Buildings: Are there limits on the size, height, or number of outbuildings, such as barns, workshops, or sheds? Some zones limit the total percentage of the land that can be covered by impervious surfaces (buildings, driveways, etc.).
  • Livestock and Fowl: If you plan to raise animals, confirm any regulations regarding setbacks from property lines, manure management, and limits on the number or type of animals per acre (e.g., a limit on swine or chickens).

The Challenge of Changing Zoning

If a property is not zoned for your specific use, you might consider a rezoning or a variance, but these are complex, costly, and carry no guarantee of approval.

1. Zoning Variance or Conditional Use Permit

  • Variance: An exception granted when strict application of the zoning law creates a unique and unnecessary hardship due to the specific physical characteristics of the property (e.g., steep slopes prevent compliance with a setback rule). It is not granted simply for convenience.
  • Conditional Use Permit (CUP): Allows a use that is generally compatible with the area but requires case-by-case review and conditions (e.g., a small farm stand in a residential-agricultural zone).

2. Rezoning a Property

Rezoning is the formal process of changing the entire zone classification (e.g., from Agricultural to Commercial). This is significantly more difficult, especially in rural areas where local governments prioritize preserving the area’s current character.

Step
Detail & Challenge
Consult the Master Plan
Local governments have a Comprehensive or Master Land Use Plan. Any proposed rezoning must align with this plan’s long-term vision. If your change contradicts it, approval is unlikely.
Application and Fees
Requires a formal application, substantial fees, and submission of detailed plans (site, traffic, environmental).
Public Hearings
You’ll present your case to the local Planning Commission or Zoning Board. Neighbors and community members, especially those opposed to the change, will have the opportunity to voice their opposition. Strong community resistance is a common hurdle.
Time and Cost
The process can take 6 to 12 months or longer, incurring significant legal, engineering, and consulting costs. Approval is never guaranteed.

Observation: The bottom line is that you should never buy a rural property banking on a successful rezoning. Only purchase land that is already zoned for your essential needs.

How to Research a Property’s Zoning

The most reliable information comes directly from the local government, not just the seller or real estate agent.

  1. Identify the Jurisdiction: Determine if the property is within city limits, a township, or solely under county jurisdiction. In rural areas, the county planning and zoning department is usually the correct authority.
  2. Obtain the Parcel Number (APN): You’ll need the Assessor’s Parcel Number to search records. You can usually get this from the listing agent or the county assessor’s website.
  3. Contact the Planning Department: Call or visit the County Planning and Zoning Department. Give them the APN and your intended use. They can confirm the current zoning, provide the official zoning ordinance (the rulebook), and tell you if your plans are permitted, require a special permit, or are prohibited.
  4. Check for Other Restrictions: Zoning is one layer. You must also check the deed for restrictive covenants (HOA-like rules put in place by a developer) and look up easements (legal rights for others, like utility companies or neighbors, to use a portion of your land).

Conclusion

The allure of rural property, with its promise of space, freedom, and self-sufficiency, is undeniable, but local zoning regulations govern the reality. Before you sign a single document, performing thorough due diligence on a property’s existing zoning classification, permitted uses, and any restrictive covenants is not just advisable; it is absolutely essential.

Relying on a costly and uncertain rezoning process is a path fraught with risk. By proactively consulting the local planning and zoning department to confirm that the property’s current legal status aligns perfectly with your immediate and long-term vision, you ensure that your dream piece of rural land remains a source of enjoyment, not a regulatory nightmare.

Related Stories: Firm to Farm
Key legal & tax insights for farmers, like accumulated earnings tax, using 401(k) to start farming, ag data in court, and maximizing farm home-sale exclusions when selling your farm.
A U.S. Federal District Court upheld an Arizona rancher’s legal complaint against the Biden Administration’s decision to halt construction on a U.S.-Mexico border wall violated environmental law and the plaintiff’s property rights.
In his latest Firm to Farm blog post, Ag Legal & Taxation Expert Roger McEowen examines contracts, insurance, and property rights and how those legal processes can impact your farm or ranch operation.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

Two more key developments in ag law and taxation from 2023, a crackdown on biodiesel fraud and developments in self-employment taxation (#7 and #6), are the topic of today’s Firm to Farm blog post, the second in a series by RFD-TV agri-legal expert Roger McEowen.
The start of the review of the most important ag law and tax developments of 2023—that is the topic of today’s Firm to Farm blog post by RFD-TV agri-legal expert Roger A. McEowen
Recent developments in ag law and tax — that is the topic of today’s Firm to Farm blog post by RFD-TV-Agri-Legal Expert Roger McEowen.
If you are thinking about making substantial gifts and/or doing so in a complicated fashion, make sure to get good professional advice beforehand. In his latest Firm to Farm blog post, RFD-TV Agri-Legal Expert Roger McEowen tackles the complex rules surrounding financial gifts, charitable donations and estate transfer.
But, what does “detached and disinterested” mean? When is a transfer of funds a gift — at least in the eyes of the IRS? That is the topic of today’s Firm to Farm blog post by RFD-TV’s Agri-Legal Expert Roger A.McEowen.
Just how much are probate fees? How are they determined? That is the topic of today’s Firm to Farm blog post by RFD-TV’s Agri-Legal Expert Roger A. McEowen.