H-2A Wage Ruling Creates Uncertainty for Agricultural Employers

Roger McEowen discusses the federal court ruling on H-2A wage rates and its implications for agricultural employers.

fruit it baskets at the farmer's market

Assorted fruits at a farm stand. (Adobe Stock)

Adobe Stock

TOPEKA, KAN. (RFD-TV) — A recent federal court decision has created uncertainty for agricultural employers who rely on the H-2A program after the court found several parts of the Department of Labor’s wage methodology unlawful.

Roger McEowen with the Washburn School of Law joined Market Day Report to discuss what the ruling means for farmers and ranchers and what employers should be watching as the Department of Labor develops a new methodology.

Court Challenges H-2A Wage Methodology

In his interview with RFD-TV, McEowen said the case centered on the Department of Labor’s formula for determining the minimum wage farmers must pay H-2A workers.

The court found several important parts of the methodology unlawful under the Administrative Procedure Act.

“It’s a procedural type issue there,” McEowen said. “The court said that DOL had not adequately explained its choices. And in some instances had improperly bypassed the normal notice and comment process, which is required under the Administrative Procedure Act.”

However, the court did not immediately eliminate the existing wage rates. Instead, the court ordered the Department of Labor to develop a new methodology.

Current H-2A Wage Rates Remain in Effect

For farmers and ranchers currently using the H-2A program, McEowen said the wage rates will not change immediately.

“For now I’d say, don’t change what you’re doing based solely on the decision,” he said. “The current annual effective wage rates remain in effect until the Department of Labor puts out the new rates.”

McEowen said employers should recognize that the current rates are temporary and that a new methodology could result in higher wage rates in the future.

“I would continue complying with the current rates, but I’d keep very good records of wages and hours and job duties and housing going forward,” he said.

Department of Labor Must Explain New Methodology

McEowen said the Department of Labor will need to explain its methodology more clearly when developing a new wage formula.

“Well, they’ve got to show their work,” he said, noting that the agency needs to explain why its methodology protects American workers from adverse wage effects and why the data being used is appropriate for agricultural labor.

McEowen said the court was particularly critical of placing about 90% of H-2A jobs into a 17th percentile wage category.

He also said substantive changes to the wage system must go through the normal notice-and-comment process so the public has an opportunity to participate before a rule is finalized.

Potential Back-Pay Exposure

While there is no current back-pay obligation, McEowen said employers should watch for potential future exposure.

The Department of Labor has notified employers that they may have to make back-pay adjustments for H-2A workers, U.S. workers and corresponding employment if the new wage methodology produces higher rates.

“But, and this is the key point to pay attention to, no employer owes back pay today,” McEowen said. “The current annual effective wage rates remain in effect while the Department later develops this new methodology the court is requiring, and the litigation continues.”

He said the Department of Labor has formally notified employers that they may owe adjustments for the period beginning September 2.

“As of today, the current annual effective wage rates still apply,” McEowen said. “There’s no present back-pay obligation. But I would say this: there is potential exposure.”

Broader Questions About Federal Agencies

McEowen said the case also raises broader questions about federal agencies’ authority and the role of the courts.

He said agencies have expertise but are not Congress and cannot simply create a new policy without staying within the authority Congress has given them.

“They have to stay within the authority Congress gave them, and they have to follow the Administrative Procedure Act and explain what they’re doing and why they’re doing it,” McEowen said.

He said courts have an important role in ensuring agencies do not exceed those boundaries, particularly when agency wage decisions can directly affect the cost of producing food in the United States.

McEowen advises agricultural employers to continue following current wage rates while keeping detailed records and closely watching the Department of Labor’s next steps.

“The bottom line, people, if you want to take away something from this, is to comply with the wage rates today,” McEowen said. “Keep your records. Watch very closely what the Department of Labor does next, because the wage rate you pay today may not be the final number.”

READ MORE: FIRM TO FARM

Related Stories
The settlements stem from a class-action lawsuit accusing major meat processors of conspiring to suppress worker wages.
Dr. Jeffrey Gold discusses warning signs of dementia and how early diagnosis can improve quality of life.
From Santa visits to a Christmas market, the new festival offers families a seasonal experience on 50 acres of farmland.
Agrievolution Alliance’s Charlie O’Brien discusses declining global farm equipment sales, stronger markets in India and China, and emerging opportunities for manufacturers.

Marion is a digital content manager for RFD-TV and FarmHER + RanchHER. She started working for Rural Media Group in May 2022, bringing a decade of digital experience in broadcast media and some cooking experience to the team.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

Wednesday, November 25, 2026 — 7:30 PM EST | 6:30 PM CST | 5:30 PM MST | 4:30 PM PST
SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 28, 2026 — 8:30 PM EST | 7:30 PM CST | 6:30 PM MST | 5:30 PM PST
SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 28, 2026 — 8 PM EST | 7 PM CST | 6 PM MST | 5 PM PST
Spend Thanksgiving Weekend with RFD-TV: Holiday Programming Features Country Music, FarmHER + RanchHER, New Series and Classic Westerns.
AARP Virginia Director Jim Dau discusses the financial burden of caregiving and how family members can help share responsibilities and support loved ones.
Montana FarmHER Kate Stephens shares her family’s farming legacy, the realities of daily farm life, and her mission to connect consumers with agriculture.
USDA Chief Economist Justin Benevidez says prices for most crops are expected to remain relatively steady over the next decade, although below the highs seen during the 2021-22 and 2022-23 marketing years.
The latest Commodity Costs and Returns forecast projects production costs reaching record levels next year, adding to the pressure on farmers already facing low crop prices and tight margins.
Mike Steenhoek with the Soy Transportation Coalition says maintaining reliable, competitive river transportation is important for managing shipping costs and keeping grain moving to market.
Michael Palantoni discusses athenahealth’s research on chronic disease rates among rural millennials and the challenges rural healthcare providers face.
LSU AgCenter horticulturist Michael Polozola explains Louisiana pecan production, orchard spacing, tree varieties, and what it takes to grow pecans for the holiday season.
Mt. Folly CEO Ben Pasley explains how the company’s regional beef model creates opportunities for farmers and ranchers while bringing locally sourced beef to Kroger stores.