Historically Low Winter Wheat Ratings Raise Yield Concerns, But Markets Lag Behind

Markets have been slow to respond as crop stress worsens across major winter wheat regions, where quality ratings have fallen to multi-decade lows.

MANHATTAN, Kan. (RFD NEWS) — The U.S. winter wheat crop is drawing renewed attention from traders and analysts after condition ratings fell to their weakest levels in decades, raising concerns about yield potential heading into harvest.

Market analyst Brian Hoops said current ratings are the lowest since May 1989, even as the market has struggled to respond to deteriorating crop conditions.

“That’s now the lowest rating since May of 1989 for this winter wheat crop, and yet wheat market struggles in here,” Hoops said. “We’re seeing a little bit of harvest and not hearing very good yields. The market’s not responding to this positive news.”

Despite the weak condition ratings, Hoops noted the wheat market has not yet shown a sustained rally, suggesting traders may be waiting for additional signals, including harvest data and options expiration activity later in the month.

“This probably tells us we’re going to see a dip in here before we see a rally like a post-harvest type rally; usually that occurs in mid to late June,” he said. “Maybe the options have to expire first before we see that type of a rally, but at some point here, I think the wheat market may take another move higher. It really doesn’t have to ration demand. It just has to make sure that we don’t run out of supplies, and we had a big cushion going into this marketing here.”

This week’s USDA Crop Progress report shows 44 percent of the winter wheat crop rated poor to very poor, underscoring ongoing stress in key growing regions like Kansas.

Economists at Kansas State University say weather variability remains a major factor, with conditions described as “mixed and spotty” across the state.

Agricultural economist Dan O’Brien said some areas of Kansas have experienced significant crop abandonment due to drought stress, while other regions remain more resilient.

“With regard to moisture, generally, the favorite answer of anybody answering about Kansas conditions is that it’s mixed and spotty,” O’Brien said. “It’s just not consistent, but a lot of dry areas and lots of concern. Of course, we came out of a time frame when we were dry enough that we really did hurt the Kansas wheat crop in parts of the state. You know, when you talk about abandonment, I’m wedded to the idea of resiliency in Kansas wheat because it will surprise you year after year after year with producing more than you think it would.”

He added that estimates of over 20 percent abandonment may be high overall, but conditions vary widely depending on location.

“Estimates of 20-25% abandonment seem awfully high in terms of what we look at historically, but it really just depends on which part of the state you’re driving through,” he said. “We’ve had wheat in the central part of the state, where the wheat fields a month ago were yellow, which meant they had already been sprayed and killed off because they gave up on the wheat. They’re going to plant no-till corn or sorghum into it, probably.”

O’Brien says final yields are expected to come below previous years, with early estimates from the Kansas wheat tour placing production around 38.7 bushels per acre.

Related Stories
Farm CPA Paul Neiffer says producers forced to sell livestock due to drought may have several tax options available.
Researchers say demand for green fertilizers continues growing alongside environmental regulations and rising consumer interest.
Bushel’s State of the Farm report found that many producers are willing to test new tools.
The proposed merger between Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern would create the nation’s first transcontinental railroad connecting the East and West coasts under a single carrier.
North Dakota State University’s Dr. Shawn Arita joins us to break down new research on U.S. ag export losses tied to retaliatory tariffs and what they signal for trade moving forward.
With U.S. cattle supplies already tight, drought response remains a long-term supply issue.

Marion is a digital content manager for RFD News and FarmHER + RanchHER. She started working for Rural Media Group in May 2022, bringing a decade of digital experience in broadcast media and some cooking experience to the team.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

RFD News Farm Legal Expert Roger McEowen discussed red flags landowners should watch for during property transactions.
ASFMRA’s Howard Halderman says several economic and policy issues are continuing to influence the farmland market.
Lewis Williamson with HTS Commodities joined us to discuss spring planting progress and the outlook for trade and demand as the season continues.
USMCA review nears a critical stage as the U.S. and Mexico advance talks while Canada risks being left behind, raising concerns across North American agriculture trade.
Sen. Jerry Moran of Kansas joins us to discuss the Food for Peace program’s Kansas roots, its place in the Farm Bill, and the importance of the USDA’s visit to the state.
USDA approves disaster aid for Pennsylvania orchard and specialty crop growers after April freezes caused major crop damage statewide.