“It’s Been Confusing": Rep. Dan Newhouse says farmworkers are on edge right now

There have been big moves this week around ag labor and the illegal workforce. Some appreciate President Trump’s recent comments looking to shield farms from deportations, but one ag lawmaker says the back-and-forth is taking a toll.

“It’s been a little confusing, absolutely has been. And I think there’s probably a little distrust out there on the part of workers and whether they should show up today or not because they’re exposing themselves. And that fear that you mentioned is real. The fear of deportations.”

Earlier this week, President Trump told reporters that he is working on a “temporary pass,” allowing
illegal farmworkers to stay in the United States while still paying taxes. Trump says farmers would have more say in the situation, too, noting America’s producers are not hiring violent offenders.

“One thing we’re seeing, though, particularly in our industry, is that the costs of the H-2A program are getting so high that it’s getting impossible for farmers to actually pay those high rates and high costs, because we also have transportation to and from Mexico. We also have the contract fees for acquiring the visas,” said Mike McCarthy.

McCarthy adds that housing costs are another expense that are on the hook for. He calls the current H-2A program unsustainable, warning he and others might go out of business without congressional action.

Related Stories
Rural population growth supports long-term stability of the ag workforce.
Texas rancher says illegal border crossings have slowed significantly, with fewer encounters reported over the past year.
Labor supply may shift, but uncertainty remains for producers.
Hiring may ease slightly, but labor shortages remain persistent.
Reduced driver supply may increase freight costs this season.
New wage rules improve accuracy but may still raise labor costs.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

National Sorghum Producers CEO Tim Lust said farmers face a challenging year with strong supply, murky trade conditions, and uncertain access to their largest market: China.
RFD-TV Markets Expert Tony St. James breaks down the state of agribusiness and harvest progress across the U.S. for the week of Monday, September 15, 2025.
Missouri Cattle RanchHER Alda Owen joined us on Monday’s Market Day Report to talk about the all-new episode of FarmHER + RanchHER, which premieres on Thursday, Sept. 19!
U.S. trade talks with China resume, but meat industry leaders say dealing with shifting demand and market uncertainty is nothing new in this side of the ag sector.
Tariffs are pushing up input costs, with fertilizer prices rising $100 per ton and machinery costs climbing due to steel and parts duties.
Year-round sales of E-15 are another major topic on Capitol Hill, which, according to Rep. Adrian Smith (R-NE), is one issue up for debate this session with significant bipartisan support.