USDA Defends $750M New World Screwworm Strategy; Calls Texas Proposal ‘Clickbait’

“USDA can no longer keep wasting its time and personnel to deploy Commissioner Miller’s infamous traps, which USDA has deployed, tested, and has proven ineffective.”

WASHINGTON (RFD-TV) — The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) is pushing back against what it calls “ineffective solutions” proposed by Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller in the fight against New World Screwworm (NWS).

In an exclusive statement to RFD-TV News, USDA officials defended their $750 million plan to build a sterile fly production facility at the southern border— calling it the most aggressive response in U.S. history — and also accused Miller of disregarding proven methods for quick publicity.

“USDA, in conjunction with the entire federal government, has launched the most aggressive plan to combat the New World Screwworm in the history of our country, including committing up to $750 million to build a sterile fly production facility at the Southern Border at Moore Air Base,” the USDA spokesperson said.

Commissioner Miller advocates for using fly bait traps to combat the cattle parasite — a plan he said he will implement in his state, “with or without buy-in from the USDA,” and claims could knock out NWS in 90 days.

“Commissioner Miller is blatantly disregarding tried and true NWS offensive strategies in favor of clickbait publicity stunts,” the USDA spokesperson told RFD-TV News. “USDA looks forward to working with any and all partners who seek to find REAL solutions to defeat the NWS.”

"USDA can no longer keep wasting its time and personnel to deploy Commissioner Miller’s infamous traps, which USDA has deployed, tested, and has proven ineffective."
USDA Spokesperson

The USDA says that they tried Miller’s method, and it “has proven ineffective,” saying its own traps caught thousands of flies in a month, while Miller’s only trapped one.

“We won’t defeat it overnight,” said the USDA spokesperson. “It will take all of us at the federal and state level working together to combat it.”

The USDA maintains that its five-step plan to address NWS, which includes the sterile fly facility and up to $100 million in investments for biosecurity innovation, is a proven method with tangible results, unlike Miller’s proposal.

“USDA will remain focused on our five-pronged plan to boost sterile fly production and dispersal and work with Mexico to increase real-time surveillance in Latin America — real actions that are delivering results,” the USDA spokesperson said."Never before has the U.S. been this involved on the ground in Mexico. This is a national security issue, and it has the full attention of the Trump administration.”

Read the USDA’s Full Statement to RFD-TV News below:


USDA, in conjunction with the entire federal government, has launched the most aggressive plan to combat the New World Screwworm in the history of our country, including committing up to $750 million to build a sterile fly production facility at the Southern Border at Moore Air Base. Sterile flies are the most tried and true way to ensure the U.S. is protected from this pest. In the meantime, as the facility is built, USDA is launching up to $100 million to fund innovations that can be rapidly deployed over the next year to two years. In addition, USDA is making bold and impactful progress with Mexico on improving surveillance, trapping, increasing fly production, and putting in place movement restrictions in infected areas.

While this pest didn’t get close to the U.S. overnight, and we won’t defeat it overnight, it will take all of us at the federal and state level working together to combat it.

Following comments on the effectiveness of USDA’s plan to combat NWS and after many months of good faith collaboration with Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller on potential “solutions”, USDA can no longer keep wasting its time and personnel to deploy Commissioner Miller’s infamous traps which USDA has deployed, tested, and has proven ineffective. In one month, USDA’s traps in Panama caught thousands of New World Screwworm flies - Commissioner Miller’s traps caught ONE single NWS fly. When presented with the results of his traps underperforming, Commissioner Miller indicated USDA staff should “paint them black” to which USDA declined.

Commissioner Miller is blatantly disregarding tried and true NWS offensive strategies in favor of clickbait publicity stunts.

USDA will remain focused on our five-pronged plan to boost sterile fly production and dispersal and work with Mexico to increase real time surveillance in Latin America. Real actions that are delivering results. Never before has the U.S. been this involved on the ground in Mexico. This is a national security issue, and it has the full attention of the Trump administration.

USDA looks forward to working with any and all partners who seek to find REAL solutions to defeat the NWS.
U.S. Department of Agriculture Spokesperson

Related Stories
Tyson’s capacity cuts weaken local basis, tighten kill space, and heighten dependence on imports, signaling more volatility for producers.
Strong yields and higher cattle prices helped stabilize conditions, but weak crop prices and rising carryover debt remain major challenges for Eleventh District farmers.
Jake Charleston, with Specialty Risk Insurance, joins us now for an industry update and advice for cattle producers as they consider options for managing the risks of a murky market.
The National Milk Producers Federation will launch a new advocacy campaign to secure a final vote, urging House lawmakers to approve the bill as soon as they return from the Thanksgiving recess.
Tyson’s Nebraska plant closure and falling Cattle on Feed numbers send cattle markets tumbling. Analysts warn of tighter supplies, weak margins, and rising global competition.
Texas Ag Commissioner Sid Miller warns horse owners after EHV-1 cases linked to the Waco WPRA Finals. Horses linked to recent Waco events should be isolated and closely monitored, as early action is critical to stopping the spread of EHV-1.
One trader said the products entering the U.S. are primarily grind and trim, noting that the volume and type of beef, on its own, should not cause a major disruption. However, he says fund traders are reacting heavily to headlines rather than market realities.
Agriculture Shows
From the rapid technological advances in the business of farming to the policy that helps shape the industry, growers get unparalleled perspective from these guys. Max Armstrong, Mike Pearson and Greg Soulje: the names producers have long known and trusted for agriculture news, weather, and commentary.
Watch Rural Evening News to catch up on that day’s news surrounding agriculture and markets from across the world. Along with market news, our news staff will bring you news stories covering topics including auctions, cattle, farm equipment, ranch, real estate, and much more!
Every day, “Market Day Report” delivers “live” coverage of agri-business news, weather, and commodity market information from across the world. Our market coverage is constantly updated every half-hour, bringing you the latest on the markets.
Farm Monitor shines a light on Southeastern agriculture and is the only weekly news and information program dedicated to Georgia’s largest and most important industry: agriculture.
Check out FFA Today, a fun and fast-paced show featuring fascinating stories about amazing kids and unique agriculture industries.