Record Choice Grades are Reshaping Beef Quality Premiums

Record Choice grading levels are changing how beef quality premiums are valued.

Set of various classic, alternative raw meat, veal beef steaks - chateau mignon, t-bone, tomahawk, striploin, tenderloin, new york steak. Flat lay top ... See More By ricka_kinamoto_adobe stock.png

Photo by ricka_kinamoto via Adobe Stock

LUBBOCK, TEXAS (RFD NEWS) — Fed cattle quality reached a historic milestone last week, with 89.4 percent of carcasses grading Choice or better, reshaping how premiums are determined across the beef complex. The shift is compressing traditional spreads and altering packer procurement signals.

According to USDA Agricultural Marketing Service weekly grading data, the share of cattle grading Choice or Prime climbed to an all-time record. That level significantly reduces the volume of Select beef available, which has historically been the benchmark for measuring quality premiums.

Operationally, a higher percentage of Choice and Prime narrows the Choice/Select spread, while increasing attention on the Choice/Prime differential. As Select becomes a smaller portion of the grading mix, pricing leverage increasingly centers on Prime premiums and branded beef program eligibility.

The trend reflects long-term shifts in genetics, feeding practices, and carcass weights. Longer days on feed and selection for marbling have steadily lifted quality grades over the past decade, even as cattle numbers tighten nationally.

Looking ahead, sustained high grading percentages could redefine how futures spreads and cash market negotiations interpret quality signals.

"Farm-Level Takeaway: Record Choice grading levels are changing how beef quality premiums are valued."
Tony St. James, RFD NEWS Markets Specialist
Related Stories
Expect firm demand for dependable HRS and SW, steady movement in HRW, more sorting on SRW, and selective bids on durum until full milling results are released.
Dr. Todd Davis, Chief Economist with the Indiana Farm Bureau, shares a snapshot of his state’s harvest conditions and insights from producers.
Market analyst Kevin Huddleston said news of trade deals could rebound cotton prices in late fall, and producers need to be ready to strike deals.
Shaun Haney, host of RealAg Radio, joined us to break down the latest data on Canadian farmland values and share insights on how it impacts producers.
Key signs of the U.S. beef herd’s recovery are improved pasture conditions, lower feed costs, and increased regulatory alignment and support for producers to implement targeted grazing practices.
Congress has just over a month of working days left for the year. Plan for uneven USDA service until funding is restored, and closely monitor Farm Bill talks, as avoiding Permanent Law before January 1 is the single biggest risk to markets and milk prices.

Tony St. James joined the RFD-TV talent team in August 2024, bringing a wealth of experience and a fresh perspective to RFD-TV and Rural Radio Channel 147 Sirius XM. In addition to his role as Market Specialist (collaborating with Scott “The Cow Guy” Shellady to provide radio and TV audiences with the latest updates on ag commodity markets), he hosts “Rural America Live” and serves as talent for trade shows.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

RFD-TV Markets Expert Tony St. James breaks down the state of agribusiness and harvest progress across the U.S. for the week of Monday, September 15, 2025.
U.S. trade talks with China resume, but meat industry leaders say dealing with shifting demand and market uncertainty is nothing new in this side of the ag sector.
Tariffs are pushing up input costs, with fertilizer prices rising $100 per ton and machinery costs climbing due to steel and parts duties.
Harvested acres are estimated at 90.0 million, making this year’s corn crop one of the largest since the 1930s.
U.S. producers are holding off on equipment investments amid financial pressure, market uncertainty, a rising demand for diesel, and growing desperation for trade wins.
How many burgers could you buy instead of a house?