What Makes a Great Steak? Outback’s “Chief Steak Officer” Breaks It Down

Only 41% of Americans feel confident ordering the right steak. Outback Steakhouse CSO Chef Efrem Cutler shares tips on steak cuts, marbling, tenderness, seasoning, and choosing the right cut for your taste.

hawaiian ribeye steaks with grilled pineapple and pepper salad_NCBA.jpg

Hawaiian Ribeye Steaks with Grilled Pineapple & Red Pepper Salad

TAMPA, Fla. (RFD-TV) — Beef is a familiar topic on Market Day Report, but this time the focus is on the steak. A new survey shows just 41 percent of Americans say they are confident in their knowledge of different steak cuts.

Chef Efrem Cutler, chief steak officer for Outback Steakhouse, joined us on Tuesday’s program to break down popular cuts, preparation, and what goes into serving a great steak.

What Makes a Good Steak?

In his conversation with RFD-TV, Cutler says quality starts well before the steak reaches the kitchen.

“It’s the quality that we command with our butchers as well as our farms, and we get great steaks coming into the restaurant,” Cutler said.

From there, steak experts in the kitchen follow specific seasoning and cooking methods.

“When you take that care and attention to detail, you’re guaranteed to get a great one when you come in to Outback Steakhouse,” he said.

Understanding Different Beef Cuts

Cutler broke down several steaks, including the New York strip, barrel-cut filet, center-cut sirloin, and Delmonico.

The barrel-cut filet is described as the most tender steak, while the Delmonico is a 15-ounce cut from the chuck end of the ribeye.

Cutler said the Delmonico features three different muscles, creating different textures and flavors.

For leaner cuts such as center-cut sirloin and barrel-cut filet, Cutler said Outback uses its traditional seasoning before searing the steak and cooking it to the proper temperature. The steak then rests, is brushed with butter, and is served.

Cutler said the sirloin is particularly tender and has been part of the restaurant’s “best ever” campaign.

The Delmonico is chargrilled with a special seasoning, while the New York strip balances marbling and leanness.

“You’ve got a nice marbling similar to the ribeye, but it’s a lot leaner, and you get a little bit firmer taste,” Cutler said.

What Does Hand-Selected and Hand-Trimmed Mean?

Cutler said chefs play an important role in selecting and preparing individual steaks because cuts can vary in thickness.

The kitchen staff is trained to choose the appropriate steak for the desired cooking temperature.

“A thicker, one-and-a-half-inch New York strip would be more rare to mid-rare,” Cutler said. “We’re a little bit thinner, maybe an inch; three-fourths would be more well.”

That attention to detail helps ensure the steak is cooked to the temperature the customer ordered.

Ordering Steak Does Not Need to be Intimidating

For diners who are unsure what cut to order, Cutler said restaurant staff can help.

Outback offers a variety of steaks, including sirloin, filet, ribeye, bone-in ribeye, Delmonico and New York strip.

Cutler said servers and front-of-house staff are trained to understand the different steaks, seasonings, and cooking methods.

“If you’re unsure about the steak you should order, we literally have highly trained servers and front-of-the-house staff that taste all of these steaks,” Cutler said.

He said servers can ask diners whether they prefer a tender, soft steak or something more marbled and firmer, then use that information to make a recommendation.

“Once you’ve had that conversation and the acknowledgment, they can get you to ensure that you get the greatest steak ever,” Cutler said.

LEARN MORE: KNOW YOUR CUT - BEEF

Related Stories
Sarah Boyle hopes to earn the chance to perform at Nashville’s historic Ryman Auditorium during CattleCon.
Farm CPA Paul Neiffer recommends working with a CPA and estate-planning attorney now to prepare for possible changes rather than waiting until after the 2028 elections.
From producing small hay bales at age 14 to working on her family’s farm, FarmHER Saydee Longhurst shares how FFA, agricultural education, and family have shaped her path in agriculture so far.
AFBF Director of Government Affairs Autumn Lankford Higgins says Farm Bureau is working with lawmakers to strengthen landowner protections and address outstanding concerns as the Senate considers amendments.

Marion is a digital content manager for RFD-TV and FarmHER + RanchHER. She started working for Rural Media Group in May 2022, bringing a decade of digital experience in broadcast media and some cooking experience to the team.

LATEST STORIES BY THIS AUTHOR:

Andy Tauer with the National Pork Board says global production and increased competition remain challenges, making continued market development and consumer education important priorities for the industry.
Ashley Brucker with American Farmland Trust says producers interested in agritourism should review the requirements and prepare early, as grants range from $5,000 to $10,000 and applications open on November 30.
ASFMRA Accredited Farm Manager Justin Bahr says high-quality farms continue to attract buyers, while producers and landowners should consider yields, input costs, and overall farm economics when setting cash rents and making farmland decisions.
RFD-TV Farm Legal Expert Roger McEowen advises farmers to document losses, prepare cash-flow projections, and work with attorneys and lenders before falling behind on payments.
Family Wheat & Hay Farm | Shelley, Idaho
Nebraska farmer and USMEF Chairman-Elect Dave Bruntz says the meat export industry must continue meeting international customers’ needs while making the most of available supplies.
Farmer Veteran Coalition representative Diego Loredo shares how the Farmer Veteran Fellowship Fund helps American heroes enter careers in agriculture and invest in their operations.
Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins says the department has hired more than 240 veterans and military spouses, more than doubling its original goal of 100 hires in 100 days.
Winter brings added risks for farms, including barn fires, frozen ponds and property damage. Chip Cortez of Specialty Risk Insurance Agency shares safety tips and insurance reminders.
Superior Livestock representative Will Yeager encourages ranchers to look beyond traditional cattle marketing and consider how investments in herd genetics can strengthen their long-term value.
USMEF President & CEO Dan Halstrom says maintaining global relationships, reaching younger consumers, and building on demand for U.S. red meat will be important priorities for the next 50 years.
StoneX Chief Commodities Economist Arlan Suderman says traders will be watching demand, South American weather, and geopolitical developments for the next market signals.
Rural Lifestyle & Entertainment Shows
Opry Live is the premier weekly broadcast and livestream of the Grand Ole Opry, featuring country music superstars, legends, and rising talent performing on stage in Nashville.
Brought to you by Gus Arrendale & Springer Mountain Farms, join dynamic bluegrass duo Dailey & Vincent as they welcome scores of fabulous bluegrass, country, and gospel music acts as special guests.
Enjoy traditional country music from modern-day troubadours The Malpass Brothers. Each episode stars the brother duo of Chris & Taylor Malpass along with a featured celebrity guest– and loads of clever humor.
Join popular polka performer Mollie Busta for her weekly “Mollie B Polka Party” on RFD-TV! The one-hour program features the nation’s top polka bands recorded on location at music festivals across the U.S.
Celebrating 16 Consecutive Seasons on RFD-TV! “The Penny Gilley Show,” starring “The Sweetheart of Country Music” herself, Penny Gilley.